In 2009 a study by Russo, Weir and Elixhauser, reported to the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, stated that out of every 1000 people ages 55 to 64 that 3.9 of them stayed in the hospital for low back pain. Low back pain was, in fact, rated the #8th reason for a hospital admission falling close behind cardiac conditions and arthritic conditions (interestingly another skeletal condition, osteoarthritis was the number two reason to enter the hospital in this ago group, second only to coronary atherosclerosis (hardening of the arteries).
A study by Legorreta (2004) looked at approximately 1.7 million people for back pain treatment. the outcomes showed, when chiropracticc care was pursued, the cost of treatment was reduced by 28%, hospitalizations were reduced by 41% and back surgery was reduced by 32%, with the cost of medical imaging X-rays, MRI’s, CT’s) being reduced by 37%.
Additionally almost 95% of the patients who received chiropractic care stated they were satisfied with their treatment. It was estimated in Legorreta’s study that if chiropractic were used as the first treatment option for back pain, it could potentially reduce US healthcare costs by more than $28 billion annually.
So why do we till have a blind eye turned on manual therapy and chiropractic?
In 2008, Cook, Cook and Worrell reported that manual therapy reported that manual therapy in a hospital based setting significantly reduced both the hospital charges and the lengths of stays in the hospitals. Wolk, a decade early, revealed that for diagnosis of low back pain, chiropractic had a 20.3% hospitalization rate while medicine had a 52.2% hospitalization rate. The chiropractic care also reduced the disability duration by 51.3%.
In 2007, Sarnat, Winterstein and Cambron stated there was a 60.2% reduction of in-hospital admissions with a 59% decrease in hospital stays, a 62% reduction in outpatient surgeries and a 85% reduction in pharmaceutical costs.
Ebrall, in an Australian study from 1992 reported that injured workers returned to work 4 times faster with chiropractic care (6.26 days vs 25.56 days) and that these patients had a much lower incidence of chronic low back pain that would require further treatment.
Anyway you look at it, chiropractic is less expensive, gets people back to work more quickly and with less disability.
Every study here implies that chiropractic should be the first line of treatment for low back pain. Imagine how much we could save the American people in terms of the length of time in pain, the side effects from pain medicines, the reduction to disability, the improvement to quality of life, the improvement to job perform, the savings cost wise for health care. All these studies and still . . . business as usual. There is no incentive for conventional medicine to change. In fact it comes with a huge price to hospitals and pharmaceuticals.
Russo, A., Wier, L.M., and Elishauser, A. 2009 September. Hospital utilization amoung near elderly adults age 55-64.
2007 Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality from http://www.hcup-us.ahrq.gov/reports/statbriefs/sb79.jsp
Legorreta, A.P. , 2004. Comparative analysis of individuals with and without chiropractic coverage. Archives of Internal Medicine. 164, 1985-1992
Cook,C., Cook, A., Worrell, T (2008), Manual therapy provided by physical therapists in a hospital based setting. JPMT 31(5).
Wolk, S. (1988) An analysis of Florida worker’s compensation medical claims for back related injuries. Journal of the American Chiropractic Association 27(7).
Sarnat, R.L., Winterstein, J., Cambron, J.A. (2007). Clinical utilization and cost outcomes from and integrative medicine independent physician association. An additional 3 yeara update. JPMT 30(4).
Ebrall, P.S. (1992). Mechanical low back pain. A comparison of medical and chiropractic management within the Victorian work care scheme. Chiropractic Journal of Australia 22(2).
Dr Jenny Crosby
Getting patients well from St Peters and St Charles in St Charles County and outlying areas for 15 years with chiropractic, traditional Chinese medicine, acupuncture, nutrition, food allergy testing, rehabilitative care and more
